Since I began my web site about lunar meteorites, I have received numerous inquiries. During 2019 I was contacted 5893 times (average: 16 per day) by 2738 different people from at least 81 countries who thought that they had found, bought, or inherited a meteorite, had questions about funny-looking rocks, wanted to sell me rocks, wanted to chat about meteorites (I don’t chat), or who chastised me because they found my admittedly rude admonishments below to be too rude. I have spent a lot of time answering e-mail messages, looking at photos, examining rocks, and bothering my colleagues who are real geologists (I am a retired lunar geochemist). Other scientists who study meteorites have had the same experience. As the public’s interest in meteorites increases and the price of rare meteorites remains high, I expect such inquiries to increase. In order to strike a balance between the use of our limited resources and providing a service to the community, I have adopted the policies described below.
I’m sorry, but you have not found a meteorite. Yes, your rock is funny-looking and different from other rocks in the area where you found it, but it doesn’t have a fusion crust or regmaglypts, so why do you think it’s a meteorite at all? Your rock has a rough exterior, unlike the smooth appearance of most stony meteorites. It’s got vesicles (holes, bubbles), which don’t occur in meteorites. Your rock is loaded with quartz or calcite, minerals that don’t occur in rocks from other bodies in the solar system. The density isn’t right for a meteorite. On the basis of my experience with the various meteorwrongs that I’ve examined, you probably have a hematite concretion or some kind of industrial by-product (slag). I have heard many wonderful stories from people who swear that they saw the rock fall, that the rock wasn’t in their driveway yesterday, or that it split their tree in two. I can’t explain how your rock got to be where you found it, but I can say that it is not a meteorite. [Nearly every rock that someone has described as “it wasn’t there yesterday” was just the right size for throwing. Really.] Not everything that falls from the sky is a meteorite. Or, as one of my correspondents put, most things that fall from the sky are not meteorites.
Even if it is a meteorite, it’s not from the Moon or Mars. As I note on my Lunar Meteorites web page, meteorites are rare, lunar meteorites are very rare. Only about 1800 meteorites have been found in the United States in the past 200 years. Less than 1 in 1000 of all known meteorites are from the Moon, and the number is about the same for Mars. No lunar meteorite has yet to be found in the temperate environment of North America or Europe; all were found in deserts of drier continents. You’ve got a better chance of winning big in the lottery than finding a lunar meteorite. You say that your rock attracts a magnet or a compass. That’s nice. Most (>95%) of meteorites (irons and ordinary chondrites) attract cheap magnets because they contain iron-nickel metal. However, lunar and martian meteorites contain little or no metal, so they’re not magnetic. (Also, some terrestrial rocks contain magnetite, which is magnetic.) Don’t tell me that your rock “looks like” one of the photos of a lunar meteorite on my web site. Many kinds of terrestrial rocks “look like” lunar meteorites. Finally, I don’t want to hear, “Maybe this is a kind of meteorite nobody’s ever seen before.” Get real.
Think of it this way. If it’s driving down the highway and it has 4 tires, 2 headlights, and a trunk, then it’s probably an automobile, not an alien spacecraft.
What You Should Do
Look at the photos of meteorites: fusion crust | regmaglypts | more photos. Go through the Self-Test Check-List. Look at this information about meteorite statistics. If you’re still confused, try my Some Meteorite Realities website where many of the same points are stated in a different way.
I urge you to saw your rock in two or cut an “end” off with a tile saw. (Or, bring it to a local rock shop where they are likely to have a rock saw.) Most (89%) stony meteorites are ordinary chondrites. Metal grains are easily visible on the sawn face of an ordinary chondrite.
If you contact me, please use e-mail. Do not call me on the telephone, don’t send a letter, and don’t send me samples. I do not answer or respond to telephone calls about meteorites. Why? I can’t identify meteorites over the telephone. (Nobody can.) Also, I don’t hear well and often don’t understand people who call me on the phone. If you send a letter, I probably won’t answer it because it takes too much time. Same with samples. (Did I mention that I’m retired?) So, e-mail me. Please include a few good digital photos with your e-mail. If the photos are not in focus or poorly exposed, they are of no use to me. Include some object like a hand, coin, or ruler in the photographs for scale.
I admit that I cannot determine with certainty whether or not a rock is a meteorite from a photo. Sometimes I can say with great certainty “That rock is not a meteorite” and rarely I say “Yes, that rock looks like a meteorite to me.” My most common response, however, is “That rock is lacking the most characteristic feature of a meteorite, a fusion crust, so I have no reason to suspect that it’s a meteorite.”
I am likely not to respond at all to the following types of e-mail.
- Your message has little or nothing to do with meteorite identification. Example: “What kind of rock is this?” Take it to a rock and mineral shop or a rock and mineral show.
- You didn’t ask me a question.
- You haven’t told me why you think your rock is a meteorite based on the information that I’ve provided here.
- The object in photo is clearly not a meteorite to anyone who has studied the info provided here.
- You want me to buy rocks or help you sell rocks that you think are meteorites.
- You didn’t send me any photos.
- You sent photos of several or many rocks. What? You think you found more than one meteorite? I don’t have time to look at your whole rock collection.
- You’ve contacted me several times before and I’ve told you your rocks don’t look like meteorites. You are not learning.
- You sent me a video. I won’t watch it. I just want sharp, well illuminated still photos.
- You don’t tell me your real name.
- I’ve given you my opinion and you argue with me. If you don’t like my free opinion, get a second opinion.
If I think the rock in the photos might be a meteorite, then I will respond.
Please do not send me send me samples. I don’t classify or “test” meteorites. I won’t send them back to you. I’m a poor retired university scientist.
If you are particularly certain that your rock is a meteorite and you really want to convince me (or any other scientist), then I urge you to obtain a chemical analysis at a commercial rock-testing laboratory. I recommend Actlabs. Ask for analysis code Meteorite(ICP/ICPMS). I have no financial interest in Actlabs, I just know they do a good job. First, however, send me some photos of the rock so I get a chance to say, “If that rock were mine, I wouldn’t spend the money to have it analyzed.”
Actlabs requests a 5-gram sample (a US nickel weighs 5 grams). However, they can do the analysis on as little as 1 gram if you request “no LOI” (loss on ignition, i.e., % weight loss when the sample is heated to a high temperature). LOI is sometimes useful, but never critical, for determining whether or not a rock is a meteorite.
Send me a copy of the report (XLS file) that Actlabs sends you and I will tell you whether the rock composition is consistent with that of a meteorite. A chemical analysis is sufficient for me to be able to say “yes, it is” or “no, it’s not” 99 times out of 100. If I conclude that the composition of your rock is not consistent with any kind of meteorite, then I will probably not be able to tell you just what kind of rock it really is. Rock-type identification requires other kinds of tests.
Check your own data with “Chemical Composition of Meteorites“
If you have found a chunk of metal that you think might be an iron meteorite, you need to have it analyzed (at a minimum) for iron (Fe), nickel (Ni), chromium (Cr), and manganese (Mn). Unfortunately, I do not know a lab that does this cheaply. If somebody out there does, let me know.
December 3, 2019: I have received results of analyses of 547 samples from Actlabs and more than 100 samples from other labs. Only 10 of the rocks were meteorites, all ordinary chondrites. Half of these were from northern Africa or the Middle East and a couple, I believe, were stones that someone had bought or inherited.